Related
The Skywalkers are the foundation of theStar Warsfilms . In fact , the absolute majority of cinema – the entirety of the original trilogy , prequel trilogy and sequel trilogy – are all part of the Skywalker saga .
Much of the original trilogy ’s greatness stem from Luke Skywalker , his sister Leia , and their father Anakin Skywalker as Darth Vader . The prequel trilogy offer more sixth sense into the Skywalker family ’s yesteryear as it follow Anakin ’s journey to becoming Darth Vader .
The sequel trilogy has enriched the story of the Skywalker family even more with an older Luke , Leia , and her Word Ben Solo – or Kylo Ren as most call him . Even outside the Skywalker saga the family ’s mien persists , such as Darth Vader ’s scene - slip performance inRogue One .
As beloved and high developed as they may be , a issue of inconsistencies and question mark still ring the Skywalker folk . Some of these progeny were created by the ever - expanding stories constantly added to theStar Warsuniverse while others have existed for many age . Others , especially those related to the still evenhandedly new subsequence trilogy , may be answered in time . After all , fan debate certain plot holes in the originalStar Warsmovie for forty years before they were addressed inRogue One . As of now , though , there are still plenty of headland - itch elements fence in the Skywalkers .
Let ’s take a looking at at20 thing That Make No sentience About The Skywalker Family .
Anakin’s Birth
The prequel trilogy introduced fans to Anakin ’s mother Shmi Skywalker . Her pity and inner forte influenced Anakin in many positivist ways , but her death help trip the dark within her son . Anakin ’s father , on the other hired hand , remained a mystery in the pic . Qui - Gon Jinn enquire Shmi about Anakin ’s don inThe Phantom Menace . Shmi tells Qui - Gon " There was no Father-God . I carried him , I give birth , I raised him . I ca n’t explain what happened . "
Using Shmi ’s negotiation , along with other entropy in theStar Warsuniverse , many sports fan read this as Shmi basically having a miraculous birthing . The estimation is that Anakin was conceived by the Force for become the Chosen One and bring balance to the Force as prophesy .
The novelDarth Plagueissuggests that Anakin ’s want of father is the product of Plagueis ' experimentation . The Force intervene against the Sith ’s dark experiments and created Anakin , opt the low yet unassailable Shmi as a host for his nativity .
TheDarth Plagueisnovel is no long canyon , though , so this account no longer works . The novel remains among some of the most popular works from the Expanded Universe , so there is a prospect some elements of it , including Anakin ’s birth , will return to canyon one day . For now , however , it ’s still unclear how exactly Anakin was born in the first position .
Anakin’s Obvious Secret
Anakin ’s marriage ceremony to Padmé is think to be a secret . In order of magnitude to persist a Jedi , the secret must be kept at all monetary value , and no one other than splice attendees C-3PO and R2 - D2 are supposed to know the truth .
The problem is that Anakin and Padmé are n’t exactly subtle about it . They are frequently witness together inAttack of the Clones , Revenge of the Sith , The Clone Warsmovie and television show . Of course , being witness together does n’t equate to union . The way they interact with each other is the giveaway , though . They ’re either too intimate and emotional , or they assay to exude such a cold and professional conduct to the point that it ’s obvious they ’re trying way too hard .
Anakin engender aroused about Padmé in a mode he does n’t about anyone or anything else .
Perhaps an ordinary person would neglect all the signs , but it strain plausibility to go for that the Jedi Council was completely oblivious to the accuracy of Anakin and Padmé ’s relationship . They are Force - sensitive and read the great unwashed better than they can read themselves . They knew how Anakin operated and how he had feel about Padmé in the past . If nothing else , it seems unlikely that they did n’t even know the two of them endure together .
TheStar Wars : Forces of Destinyepisode " Unexpected Company " shows that Ahsoka Tano figured out the accuracy about Anakin and Padmé when she was Anakin ’s apprentice . Ahsoka was always talented , insightful and understood Anakin better than most . Obi - Wan seemed to surmise it , but did n’t act on his suspicions , nor did he see the full moving picture until the goal . disregardless , the the like of Yoda and Mace Windu should ’ve been able to earn it as well . Even someone who was n’t a Jedi like Senator Bail Organa could ’ve calculate it out . If he only turn around and stopped talking after speak with Anakin inRevenge of the Sith , he would ’ve seen Anakin guide towards Padmé , embracing and kissing her .
It ’s possible but still dubious that the Jedi Council , specially Obi - Wan give his relationships and understanding of both Anakin and Padmé , knew the truth but fundamentally chose not to cope with it . With that same hubris Luke Skywalker would by and by tell Rey plagued the Jedi Order and allowed Darth Sidious to rise to power , the Jedi Council could ’ve turned a blind eye to the marriage as they relied to a great extent on Anakin as one of their most skilled Jedi , his future as the Chosen One , and his singular connection to Chancellor Palpatine .
The Diplomatic Mission Lie
When Darth Vader and his Stormtroopers dining table theTantive IVat the commencement ofA New Hope , both Leia and Captain Raymus Antilles are adamant that they have no knowledge of the Death Star plans . They insist that theTantive IVis a counselor ship on a diplomatical mission .
The takings with this lie is that Vader consider theTantive IVflying away with the Death Star plans at the end ofRogue One . In his pastime to recover the stolen Death Star plans , Vader rent out legion rebels inRogue One ’s iconic hallway scene before one of them steal onto theTantive IVwith said plans . Leia and Captain Antilles can be admired for boldly defying the terrific Vader . They believably should ’ve endeavor to come up with a better prevarication , though , one that would n’t contradict what had fall out only minutes ago .
Rogue One enhanced the Star Wars universe in countless fashion and even filled in plot holes fromA New Hope . The direction in whichRogue One ’s ending straightaway leads intoA New Hopeis epic to behold . Yet , the contradiction of the diplomatic mission lie is one way thatRogue Onecreated a new game hole forA New Hope .
A Failed Interrogation
As a prisoner aboard the Death Star , Leia is interrogated in the hope that she will reveal the Rebel Alliance ’s hidden nucleotide . Darth Vader himself conducts the interrogation . Leia resists the mind probe droid and does n’t give up the Rebellion ’s mystic base on Yavin 4 . Leia ’s lastingness with the Force for certain helped her in the billet . preparation she received as a all important penis of the Rebel Alliance , and as royalty and a pol also must ’ve prepared her to withstand such query .
It does n’t make gumption that Darth Vader could walk away from this interrogation not realizing Leia was his daughter , or at the very least that she was Force - tender .
Vader is too sinewy in the Force to be completely ignorant of both these fact . Leia ’s singular opposition to the mind investigation droid , something that Jedi were actually trained to do , should have been a gigantic hint that Leia was Force - sensible .
It ’s also hard to accept that Vader could n’t recognize that Leia was Force - sensitive considering that he train the interrogator . One of the purposes of the inquisitor was to locate Force - sensitive children so they could n’t be used against the Empire , yet the individual who trained them could n’t realize that the woman he was interrogate was Force - sensitive .
Scared Of Sand
Darth Vader does n’t realize until the original trilogy that his children survived and did n’t pass along with their mother . This explain why he does n’t search for them in the time full stop betweenRevenge of the SithandA New Hope .
Vader still had plenty to search for , though , admit his former schoolmaster and Order 66 survivor Obi - Wan Kenobi . Tatooine seems like a logical place to research consider how the pasts of both Vader and Obi - Wan are linked to Tatooine . Fans joke that Vader did n’t repay to Tatooine because of his hatred for sand , just as Anakin say Padmé in one of the most oft mocked lines fromAttack of the Clones . Amusing as it may be , it does n’t suffice as an account for why Vader did n’t go to Tatooine .
Even when it ’s clear at the commencement ofA New Hopethat Leia hide the Death Star plans via the droids in the escape pod , which derive to the open of Tatooine , Vader does n’t go in person to retrieve the all - crucial plans and instead sends troops to do the dirty body of work . It ’s as if Vader wanted to avoid Tatooine at all costs . His aversion belike has more to do with the abominable memories it hold than the George Sand itself , but it seems like retrieving the Death Star plans himself should take precedency , particularly considering what they intend to Emperor Palpatine .
The comics reveal that Vader did n’t give to Tatooine until afterA New Hopewhen the Emperor ordered him to go thereto negotiate with Jabba the Huttregarding resources the Empire require in the wake of the Death Star ’s destruction .
Painful memories and backbone aside , Vader was too powerful and fearless an mortal to stave off render to Tatooine until his superior explicitly commanded it .
No Fake Name?
Under no lot could Darth Vader , Emperor Palpatine , or anyone in the Empire get word that the child of Anakin Skywalker lived . That ’s exactly why Obi - Wan , Yoda , and Bail Organa devised a plan at the end ofRevenge of the Sithto keep the existences of Luke and Leia secret .
raise by Bail and Breha Organa , the senator and queen magnate couple of Alderaan that always wanted a child made a stack of horse sense . They ’d love and care for Leia , check that all her pauperism were assemble , and she could grow up with the name Organa . Sending Luke to Owen and Beru Lars was already a hazardous move since Vader could remember his stepbrother and his wife , and that they likely still lived on Tatooine . With Obi - Wan keep an eye on over Luke from afar as well the determination could be justified .
Even so , that does n’t explain why anyone would think it ’s a good idea for Luke to grow up with the last name Skywalker . If Vader or anyone from the Empire ever catch hint of that name , Luke ’s enigma would be out . It would n’t have been hard at all to give Luke another name , one that does n’t threaten to untie all the efforts made to keep him alive and hidden .
In fact , it is Luke ’s Skywalker name that allow Vader to learn that hehas a son in the first seat .
Barely Grieving
Luke lose a lot of mass that are important to him inA New Hope . Uncle Owen , Aunt Beru , Obi - Wan , and Biggs Darklighter are all terminated by the Empire in the film . That amount of red ink in such a short period of time is hard to process , especially for a compassionate person like Luke who in the end place the needs of his family and friends ahead of everything else .
Luke barely grieve over any of them inA New Hope , though . Moments after seeing the end of Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru , he hurries back to Obi - Wan , says he wants to be a Jedi , and does n’t even observe them again for the rest of the movie .
Obi - Wan ’s death raise the most response from Luke as he squall out , starts shooting at Stormtroopers , and then briefly pose in a sorrow - stricken daze aboard the Millennium Falcon .
It does n’t last long as he quickly proceeds to gleefully fuck up up TIE fighters . The end of Biggs furnish even less of a reaction from Luke than it did with Owen , Beru , and Obi - Wan . draw - out setting of bereavement would ’ve clashed with the tempo and smell ofA New Hope , but it still seems like there should ’ve been at least a small more of Luke grieving for his make out ones , particularly since he ’s bear witness to be a fictitious character for the most part driven by compassion for the people he bonk .
Never Acknowledging The Odd Kiss
Long before George R.R. Martin pass on the worldly concern Cersei and Jaime Lannister , popular culture ’s definitive clumsy Romance language was Luke and Leia . There are a lot of romantic feelings between them inA New HopeandThe Empire Strikes Back , especially when they kiss . All romance between them is perish inReturn of the Jedi , the same film where they both identify they ’re sib . They maintain a close , strictly platonic relationship fromReturn of the Jediand onward .
They never do recognise the kiss fromThe Empire Strikes Back , or any of the romance in their early years of knowing each other . It seems like something they should ’ve address at some distributor point , if only to help with the cognitive operation of fully moving on with their living . The candy kiss in fussy is probably something they want to depart firm in the past and leave about if potential . At the same meter , it seems even more cumbersome to maintain a close family relationship without ever recognize and working through arguably the most embarrassing mo of their yesteryear .
Failing to reconcile with the past has have trouble for the Skywalkers before , just as Leia never severalize her boy that Darth Vader was his grandfather would later contribute to his transformation into Kylo Ren . Luke go bad into ego - imposed exile and Ben Solo becomes Kylo Ren because of their trouble to handle with the past times , and Luke and Leia refusing to recognize their preceding romance is just as harmful .
Luke’s Exponential Power Growth
Luke learns a great raft from Yoda during his training on Dagobah . He ’s still evince to be a novice in certain means with the Force and as a Jedi , though , especially in his affaire d’honneur against Darth Vader inThe Empire Strikes Back . Roughly a year passes betweenThe Empire Strikes BackandReturn of the Jedi . It ’s made clear inReturn of the Jedithat Luke ’s reunion with Yoda is the first meter he ’s returned since rushing off to keep open his booster duringThe Empire Strikes Back .
All this information make it ill-defined how Luke becomes a much more powerful and confident Jedi betweenThe Empire Strikes BackandReturn of the Jedi . He did n’t have any further training from Yoda in that time menstruation . It does n’t seem like Obi - Wan ’s Force ghost was helping him out either . Luke ’s conversation with Obi - Wan ’s Force ghost inReturn of the Jedisuggests that he and Luke have n’t spoken since Darth Vader exact to be Luke ’s Father of the Church . There ’s a fan hypothesis thatAhsoka could ’ve met Lukeduring this time period and provided him with the grooming necessary to make such significant gains , but it ’s just a theory at this level .
There ’s a sure degree of preparation and field Luke could ’ve achieved all on his own . Obi - Wan and Yoda render a solid foundation of training . That foundation garment mixed with Luke ’s raw talent and power and a newfound sense of discipline and purpose followingThe Empire Strikes Backcould’ve provided him with what he needed to advance as a Jedi . He ’s become a bite too powerful and advanced to have experience no education in this time period , though . Unless the Ahsoka theory becomes truthful , Luke ’s exponential maturation in power and self-confidence does n’t make much sense .
Luke’s Green Lightsaber
Along with his accelerated growth with the Force , Luke also has a trade name raw unripe lightsaber by the time ofReturn of the Jedi . Luke needed a new lightsaber after the previous bluish one , originally belonging to his father , plump into the depths of Bespin along with his severed hand . How Luke acquire his green lightsaber is not so straightforward , even with theReturn of the Jedideleted scene that shows him finishing its construction on Tatooine .
A kyber crystal is call for to power a lightsaber . They were never easy to acquire in the first piazza , but they would be even more challenging to find in the prison term time period betweenThe Empire Strikes BackandReturn of the Jedi .
Jedi younglings used to go to the major planet Ilum to undergo the ritual of passage known as the gather where they found and harvested the kyber crystal that would power their lightsabers . The Empire drained Ilum of all its kyber crystal as they needed the unique resource to power the Death Star ’s superweapon . On Jedha and many other satellite throughout the wandflower , the Empire also drained them dry of their kyber crystals in fiat to make the Death Star ’s superweapon a reality .
This means that by the period in betweenThe Empire Strikes BackandReturn of the Jedi , it would be incredibly unmanageable for Luke to locate a kyber watch glass . Even if he did , he probably would n’t know how to make a lightsaber . His premature lightsaber was build long ago . Neither Obi - Wan nor Yoda teach him how to make one and Luke did n’t have the sacred Jedi texts that he would later grow , texts which will likely show Rey how to construct a lightsaber .
